Analysis: Is Square the Least expensive Charge Card Processor For The Business?

accept mobile credit card payments

We’re generally requested whether Square may be the least expensive charge card processor for confirmed business. Sometimes the reply is obvious, other occasions it&#8217s more difficult. For those who have a greater-volume business (say, $10K monthly or even more in card payments), you’ll be able to probably look for a better prices plan than Square offers. What should you&#8217re a minimal-volume business searching for any mobile processing option. Is Square always the very best bet?

Good sense states that interchange-plus prices is the greatest value you will get. It&#8217s even the most transparent plan. Because of the confusion and frustration that emerges from tiered prices, it&#8217s no real surprise interchange-plus caught in route it did. That stated, very few mPOS processors offer it. Those that do frequently provide it included in a bigger monthly subscription package, which makes it hard to separate out the various costs (like a shopping cart software, virtual terminal, etc.). But there’s one option that provides you with interchange-plus prices without any fancy add-ons: Payline Mobile.

At .5% + $.20 markup over interchange for that base plan, Payline Mobile is among the least costly credit card merchant account-based mobile processing options. And all that you should do a account is process enough card-based transactions to create $25 monthly in processing charges. Should you be less than perfect, Payline will undoubtedly bill the difference rather of charging yet another fee. That&#8217s pretty spectacular, to tell the truth.

Just how much must you process with Payline Mobile to satisfy that $25 monthly minimum? So how exactly does that rival that which you&#8217d pay with Square? I sitting lower and crunched much more figures than I’d normally like simply to find out whether this interchange-plus plan is indeed a better deal.

Crunching the Figures: How to locate Your Break-Even Point

To begin, calculating the break-even point for percentage based transactions is fairly easy. The formula is simply your processing volume multiplied through the percentage. However, because we be aware of break-even point, $25, we have to shuffle the formula around a little.

  • Breakeven = processing volume (y) * processing rate (%)
  • $25 = y * %
  • y = $25 / %
  • y = ?

Here’s where things get tricky. Dealing with firms that charge only a percentage (like Square) is simple.

To calculate actual charges by having an interchange-plus plan, you’ll need three information: (1) your average interchange rate, (2) your average ticket size and (3) quantity of transactions OR monthly volume. (As long as you’ve your ticket size and one of these simple information, you are able to calculate another.)

We’re presuming a typical interchange of just one.54% + $.12. That’s fairly usual for most retailers, however if you simply process lots of American Express or business and rewards cards, you are very likely a greater rate. Based on which processor you select, by hand entering transactions (rather of swiping or dipping) will affect your costs.

We&#8217re going to check out two average ticket sizes, $20 and $45, and have fun with a couple of different monthly volumes so that you can begin to see the variations.

The final little bit of information we have to run the figures is processing rates. Square&#8217s rates are 2.75% for swiped transactions. Payline Mobile offers two plans, Spark and Surge.

Spark Plan Rates

  • Processing rate: Interchange + .5%
  • Per-transaction fee: $.20
  • Fee every month: None

Surge Plan Rates

  • Processing rate: Interchange + .3%
  • Per-transaction fee: $.20
  • Fee every month: $9.95

That&#8217s all we have to get began. To inform you the mathematics, we&#8217ll begin with the Spark Plan, since it doesn’t have fee every month. Your actual processing costs could be 2.04% + $.32 when you add some markup to the expected interchange rate.

So to work out how much you&#8217d have to tactic to generate $25 in charges, your math need to look such as this to begin:

  • BE = y * .0204
  • y = BE / .0204
  • y = $25 / .0204
  • y = 1,225.49

Our break-even point at 2.04%, is $1,225 to create $25 in charges. But we&#8217re dirty yet because we’ve that $.32 per-transaction fee to think about.

By having an average ticket size $20, that’s 61.25 transactions (1225 / 20), but let’s round lower to 61 transactions.

The next thing is to multiply the amount of transactions through the per-transaction fee:

  • 61 transactions * $.32 = $19.52.

That’s another almost $20 in charges just because of per-transaction costs, for any grand total of $44.52 in processing charges on $1,225/month in card transactions.

Hold on! Now we&#8217ve overshot our mark!

Regrettably, there&#8217s no precise method to calculate what it might decide to try create $25 in processing charges. All we can perform is have fun with the figures and find out what we should get. We all know the break-even amount is going to be under $1,225, however i don&#8217t think it&#8217ll be an excessive amount of less than that, and so i&#8217ll start at $950 and work my long ago after that if required.

I cautioned you in the beginning: I did much more math than I&#8217d normally like. 

Locating the Least expensive Charge Card Processor: In-Depth Analysis

It&#8217s here we are at some learning from mistakes. Now you know how you can perform the math, I&#8217m not likely to do it again &#8212 rather, I will place it all inside a table for you personally. I&#8217ve rounded the typical quantity of transactions to whole figures (up or lower according to standard rounding conventions).

Scenario 1:

Spark Plan,

$20 average ticket

$950/month volume

Scenario 2:

Surge Plan,

$20 average ticket

$950/month volume

Scenario 3:

Spark Plan,

$20/avg ticket

$700/month volume

Scenario 4:

Surge Plan,

$20/avg ticket

$700/month volume

Percentage Charges $19.38 $17.48 $14.28 $12.88
Per-Transaction Charges $15.36 $15.36 $11.20 $11.20
Fee Every Month None $9.95 None $9.95
Total Monthly

Processing Charges

$34.74 $42.79 $25.48 $34.03

Considering all this, you can observe by using a $20 average ticket, the break-even cost approximately $700 (just a little above by using the Surge) &#8212 and also at this rate, it&#8217s clearly cheaper to stay using the Spark plan.

To compare&#8217s sake, Square&#8217s fees are the following:

  • Square charges at $950/month: $26.13
  • Square charges at $700/month: $19.25

So yes &#8212 during these situations, Square is the foremost value. That&#8217s mostly because of the per-transaction charges being excessive.

Let’s change it out up though. If you have a greater average ticket size. Let’s go $45 per ticket.

Scenario 5:

Spark Plan,

$45 average ticket

$950/month volume

Scenario 6:

Surge Plan,

$45 average ticket

$950/month volume

Scenario 7:

Spark Plan,

45/avg ticket

$700/month volume

Scenario 8:

Surge Plan,

$45/avg ticket

$700/month volume

Percentage Charges $19.38 $17.48 $14.28 $12.88
Per-Transaction Charges $6.72 $6.72 $11.20 $11.20
Fee Every Month None $9.95 None $9.95
Total Monthly

Processing Charges

$26.10 $34.15 $25.48 $34.03

First, observe that one of these simple scenarios ends up being functionally just like Square: Scenario 5, which generates $26.10 in charges versus Square&#8217s $26.13. Therefore we have proof that interchange-plus prices Could be as good as Square at low volumes.

However, it’s also wise to spot the break-even point for Payline Mobile&#8217s $25 fee has elevated. Using the bigger transaction size, you’d need a bit more than $950 per month to interrupt even on plans — I ran the figures again and also at $1000, the charges were $25.44 + $9.95 (as many as $35.39). And again, you don&#8217t save much using the Surge plan only at that lower volume &#8212 insufficient to pay for the fee every month.

Calculating Break-Even Suggests Compare Rates

Calculating just how much you have to tactic to justify a regular monthly fee isn&#8217t very different compared to standard break-even point formula. Your break-even amount may be the fee every month, and also the percentage may be the difference backward and forward processing rates. For Payline&#8217s Spark and Surge plans, that difference is .2% (.5-.3), and also the break-even point it’s $9.95.

  • BE = y * .2%
  • $9.95 = y * .002
  • y = 9.95 / .002
  • y = 4,975

To pay for the main difference between Payline&#8217s Spark and Surge plans, you should process $4,975 monthly to warrant the fee every month.

What exactly does that appear to be like, fee wise? And just how does that appear to be when compared with Square? Let&#8217s round to $5,000/month and run the figures with $20 and $45 tickets.

Scenario 9:

Spark Plan,

$20 avg ticket

$5,000/month volume

Scenario 10:

Surge Plan,

$20 avg ticket

$5,000/month volume

Scenario 11:

Spark Plan,

$45/avg ticket

$5,000/month volume

Scenario 12:

Surge Plan,

$45 avg ticket

$5,000/month volume

Percentage Charges $102.00 $92.00 $102.00 $92.00
Per-Transaction Charges $80.00 $80.00 $56.96 $56.96
Fee Every Month None $9.95 None $9.95
Total Monthly

Processing Charges

$182.00 $181.95 $158.96 $158.91

Observe that you&#8217re really having to pay less in charges with the Surge plan since we hit the break-even point. That&#8217s good. But compare that to Square fees at $5,000/month: $137.50. You&#8217re still having to pay greater than you have to with Payline.

Let&#8217s move beyond that break-even point though. Let’s run the figures again having a monthly amount of $8,000.

Scenario 13:

Spark Plan,

$20 average ticket

$8,000/month volume

Scenario 14:

Surge Plan,

$20 average ticket

$8000/month volume

Scenario 15:

Spark Plan,

$45/avg ticket

$8,000/month volume

Scenario 16:

Surge Plan,

$45avg ticket

$8,000/month volume

Percentage Charges $163.20 $147.20 $163.20 $147.20
Per-Transaction Charges $128.00 $128.00 $56.96 $56.96
Fee Every Month None $9.95 None $9.95
Total Monthly

Processing Charges

$291.20 $285.15 $220.16 $214.11

The large takeaway here: You&#8217re having to pay considerably less in charges having a $45 average ticket over a $20 average ticket. About $70 worth, actually.

It’s also wise to compare that to Square&#8217s fees at $8,000/month: $220. Which means you begin to see low savings with Payline Data.

That lines track of things i stated earlier &#8212 that at $10,000/month, you are able to certainly improve prices than Square offers.

Altering the Variables in Charge Card Processing: Enter Spark Pay

Right now I think you’ll have a minimum of an idea of methods theoretical figures can result in very real costs. We&#8217ve proven you pretty clearly how Square ends up to be the better deal for several low-volume, low-ticket retailers.

Ultimately, It’s that per-transaction fee that actually hurts, especially at low volumes of small transactions. The greater transactions you’ve, the greater money it’s likely to drain away.  Larger ticket sizes ALWAYS obtain the advantage as it pertains lower to per-transaction charges. So locating the least expensive charge card processor isn&#8217t only a matter of searching for that cheapest percentage rate.

That’s really why PayPal’s micropayments plan saves plenty of retailers money when they process under $10 per transaction. You have to pay a greater percentage, however, you save money on the per-transaction charges.

But, I’ll freely admit that Payline Mobile&#8217s per-transaction fee is high &#8212 greater than I&#8217d like.

So let&#8217s check out a processor having a similar prices structure, however with a significantly lower per-transaction fee: Spark Pay.

Like Payline Mobile, Spark Pay offers 2 prices plans:

Spark Pay Go Plan

  • Processing rate (Visa/MasterCard/Uncover): 2.65%
  • Per-transaction fee: $.05
  • Fee every month: None

Spark Pay Pro Plan

  • Processing rate (Visa/MasterCard/Uncover): 1.99%
  • Per-transaction fee: $.05
  • Fee every month: $19

Clearly the caveat here’s that Spark Pay charges a greater rate for American Express.3.7% or 2.8% based on your plan. Making this an imperfect equation &#8212 but fairly realistic in case your American stock exchange volume is low.

Let&#8217s run one further group of figures and find out how that comes even close to Square and Payline Mobile. We&#8217ll work with similar variables &#8212 $20 and $45 average tickets, and let&#8217s say a regular monthly amount of $5,000.

Scenario 17:

Spark Pay Go,

$20 average ticket

$5,000/month

Scenario 18:

Spark Pay Go,

$45 average ticket

$5,000/month

Scenario 19:

Spark Pay Pro

$20/avg ticket

$5,000/month

Scenario 20:

Spark Pay Pro,

$45/avg ticket

$5,000/month

Percentage Charges $132.50 $132.50 $99.50 $99.50
Per-Transaction Charges $12.50 $5.56 $12.50 $5.56
Fee Every Month None None $19.00 $19.00
Total Monthly

Processing Charges

$145.00 $138.06 $131.00 $124.06

In conclusion, Square and Payline Mobile charges at $5,000/month are listed below:

  • Square: $137.50
  • Payline Mobile Spark ($20/avg ticket): $182.00
  • Payline Mobile Spark ($45/avg ticket): $158.96
  • Payline Mobile Surge ($20/avg ticket, $9.95 fee every month): $181.95
  • Payline Mobile Surge ($45/avg ticket, $9.95 fee every month): $159.91

That&#8217s a fairly factor. Why is Spark Pay&#8217s prices so diverse from Payline&#8217s once the percentage charges are fairly similar? The majority of it requires that per-transaction fee. Spark Pay&#8217s is simply $.05, that is 1/sixth the price of Payline&#8217s. And since the proportion minute rates are less than Square&#8217s, Spark Pay really ends up beating Square, too.

How you can Place Least expensive Charge Card Processor: Final Takeaways

Theoretical figures &#8212 the rates you&#8217re quoted in writing &#8212 don&#8217t tell the entire story. And extremely, they tell another story to each merchant, based on processing volume, transaction size, and the kind of cards processed.

Square along with other mPOS processors simplify the mathematics because to determine your rates, all that you should do is multiply your volume from your percentage rate. Generally, the only real value that changes the equation is by hand entering transactions.

With interchange-plus prices, there&#8217s much more to think about. Also it&#8217s hard to check out the percent signs and money involved and understand just how your rates will be different.

That&#8217s what it’s essential for you personally so that you can run the figures yourself to find out if you&#8217ve really found the least expensive charge card processor. Should you&#8217ve been processing for some time already, it is simple to get all of the figures you’ll need by searching back at the records.

Should you&#8217re a new comer to charge card processing and also you&#8217re only thinking about a mobile solution, you&#8217re most likely safest beginning by helping cover their Square or any other mPOS solution having a straight percentage-based fee. Stick to it for any couple of several weeks, then review your processing history. You will be able to run the figures and find out whether another solution might provide you with better charges.

And lastly, you should think about the general worth of the mPOS service you select. Cost is a major consideration, but make certain you think about the benefits of the various features open to you. It may be worth having to pay a little more for any feature that could save you effort and time.

But when all that is simply too much, here&#8217s a couple of simple rules to stay with:

  • The smaller sized your average transaction, the greater your per-transaction costs is going to be.
  • The bigger your average transaction, the low your per-transaction costs is going to be.
  • The low the per-transaction fee, the greater.
  • The low the percentage rate, the greater.
  • If you need to select one, you&#8217ll most likely spend less by choosing a lesser per-transaction fee. This is also true when the improvement in percentage rates is under .3%.

Best of luck in your quest to obtain the cheapest credit card processor!

Got questions regarding mPOS processing rates? Check our comment guidelines and then leave us your ideas!

The publish Analysis: Is Square the Least expensive Charge Card Processor For The Business? made an appearance first on Merchant Maverick.

“”